Cat Flag’s Guide to Understanding Millennials: Debunking Millennial Myths and Misconceptions

Millennials image from CSU Long BeachI appreciate some of the great feedback Cat Flaggers have been leaving on my previous articles discussing the Millennial generation. Thank you all, very much!

Having said that, I am far from the only person discussing the newest and largest generation to be coming of age. You will find articles about us all over the Internet as well as in magazines and newspapers. Many of these articles are not written by Millennials, but by people in older generations who occasionally fail to grasp the full picture. They also frequently draw on others who have written about Millennials, meaning that one person’s misrepresentation or misunderstanding is transformed into a full-on nationwide stereotype.

It’s high time that we tear down these myths and misconceptions, so that we can have a much deeper understanding between the generations.

“Millennials don’t respect authority!”

South Park image from MTCToys, South Park is produced by Trey Parker and Matt Stone for Comedy Central.

In fact, a survey conducted by the Center for Creative Leadership demonstrates the opposite: Millennials respect authority far more than Baby Boomers or Gen-Xers!

So, wait, what is going on here? How did Millennials get portrayed as the disrespectful generation?

The difference is in how Millennials approach authority. We absolutely respect and obey authority – when we feel it has been earned. That is the key difference, and probably the source of many an inter-generational conflict between employer and employee.

To a Millennial, the fact that you have a fancy title on your business card or an office with your name on the door does not impress. All that proves is that you have enough connections to get promoted. What Millennials respect is leadership. We want our bosses to show us that they care about their employees, that they are willing to roll their sleeves up and get in the trenches with us, that they have a vision for the company or department and want to guide us all there, and who have an answer when we ask why something has to be done a certain way. We want our bosses to clearly know what they are doing and be passionate about their work.

We do not want to work for somebody who thinks too highly of himself or herself because of his or her title, who will bark orders at employees just to keep us busy, or who resents us for asking questions and dismisses us with a “because I said so.” We want to work for somebody who sees the workplace as a team in pursuit of some goal, not as a collection of disposable pawns to do menial tasks that are beneath him or her.

We want to work for somebody we can respect, and indeed, the most common reason for a Millennial to quit a job is because he or she didn’t like the manager. More to the point, the most common reason a Millennial stays in his or her job for a long time is because he or she liked the manager. When we find a boss we like, we will be incredibly loyal. If you are a manager and having a hard time retaining Millennial employees and feel that those you do have are being disrespectful, maybe it’s time you looked at your own management style.

“Millennials are so rude! All that texting is destroying our manners!”

Texting gag from Red Oxygen

I hear this one all the time. Here’s the problem I have with that sentiment. What behaviors are considered “polite” and “impolite” changes and evolves over time.

That isn’t to excuse the cashier at Starbucks who is too busy texting to pay attention to the customer trying to get his attention. That cashier needs to find a new job. Nor does it excuse those people in the movie theater who distract you from the movie by playing Angry Birds or checking their bank balance. That is just plain inconsiderate. Believe me when I tell you that there are plenty of Millennials who will happily call those sorts of behaviors out as rude alongside you.

On the other hand, I think many of the complaints arise more out of a misunderstanding than any actual intended impoliteness. What I see among my peers is that we have adapted to our always-plugged-in, technologically-driven world by creating new rules of etiquette.

Where somebody from my parents’ generation may believe that it is always better to talk on the phone with the person you want to reach and hear an actual human voice, from what I’ve seen Millennials are actually developing a set of rules regarding when to talk and when to text. We generally see it as better to talk to a person on the phone to carry on a long conversation, to break really important and personal news, or to say anything that can’t be summarized into a few short words. If all you want to do is set up a time and place to meet, it is better to text. Just as I was writing this, my classmate and I carried out a very, very brief conversation via text message about an assignment. He just had a quick question, and I gave him a quick answer. Just the sort of thing texting was meant for.

There’s even a online guide here with some of the basic rules for how to text politely, if you want to check it out.

“Millennials are a generation of selfish, entitled brats!”

g9510.20_Millennials.Cover

This one is the myth that inspired me to write this post. In a recent issue of Time magazine, columnist Joel Stein basically insulted me and all of my peers. He’s not the first person to say this about Millennials, but he is certainly the one who was the most in-your-face about it. Or at least the guy who wrote that headline was.

I’m sick of people telling me that I’m entitled or selfish. I take personal offense to that. I also don’t think that it’s fair to my friends, classmates, or co-workers, few of whom I would categorize as narcissists. I will agree that there are SOME rude, selfish, narcissistic, and entitled Millennials. However, aren’t there rude, selfish, narcissistic, and entitled people in every generation?

In fact, this article from The Atlantic Wire specifically points out that every generation has been called selfish, narcissistic, and entitled by its parents’ generation. It shows a series of articles just like the one above – dating as far back as 1907! Here’s what I think is really going on: young, single people are generally going to be more self-centered than older, married people. Why? Older, married people have a spouse, children, and a career consuming virtually all of their attention virtually all of the time. Younger people, who are just starting out in life, haven’t worked their way up to that level of responsibility yet, so they are free to be self-centered.

Maybe it’s more obvious of a difference with Millennials because the median age of one’s first marriage is going up. In the 2010 census, the median age was 28.2 for men and 26.1 for women. It is true that a combination of factors – more students going to college, more students staying in college longer, the poor economy and job market, and the desire by Millennials to be extra picky for their life partners because of their parents’ divorce rates – is stretching out the length of time we are enjoying premarital young adulthood. Having said that, I refuse to believe that this makes us especially self-centered compared to other generations in their youths.

Some of my friends, classmates, and co-workers are already married and have families of their own. I can tell you that they are all settling down and focusing on their responsibilities, just as all parents should. Don’t worry, Boomers and Gen-Xers, the Millennials won’t be saying “Me Me Me” for much longer.

“We are approaching an ‘Age War’ as the needs of Millennials and Boomers are at odds with each other”

Anti-Ageism ad from Coloribus

This myth takes a little more explaining than the others. The story goes that as the Baby Boomers approach retirement, demographics combined with economics are making things harder for the younger generations that follow them. As more people are choosing to retire later, fewer new jobs are freed up for young entry-level workers. This, it is said, is one of the causes of those high unemployment figures for Millennials.

It is also totally bunk.

A study conducted by the Pew Research Center has found that there is no statistical evidence at all that employers are not hiring because of older workers staying on after 65. As much as the “Age War” sounds like an intuitive, common-sense conclusion to draw, the science simply doesn’t bear it out. And why should it? The older workers who are retiring later are probably mostly in high-level positions that they have earned after a long career, while the positions that Millennials would be seeking would be entry-level, bottom-of-the-totem-pole positions that are not dependent on the number of high-level positions that are currently filled.

Yet, however this myth was created, it is exactly the kind of dangerous myth that could become a part of a bigger problem. Already, we are facing a major crunch on Social Security and Medicare in the coming years if we don’t enact much-needed reforms. Already, I have seen this fact misconstrued as older generations “stealing from” the younger ones. (In fact, retiring seniors have been paying into Social Security and Medicare their whole lives, and aren’t “stealing” from anybody. The problem is budgetary policy and an outdated system, not the retirees.)

Ageism – prejudice against people due to their age – is a real thing and a real problem in our society today. Promoting conflict between generations is only going to make the problem worse. We must not let misrepresentations and rumors and blame-shifting create a conflict out of nothing. I hope that this series will help build understanding between the generations and bring us closer together, instead of further apart.

What do you think? Let me know in comments below!

Advertisements

4 Responses to Cat Flag’s Guide to Understanding Millennials: Debunking Millennial Myths and Misconceptions

  1. AuntLeesie says:

    Thank you, Robert. I’ve been enjoying this series and this blog post is perhaps your best so far. Without open dialog, there can be no understanding. What I see is everyone from twenty-somethings to ninety-somethings playing a significant role in our communities, each in their own way; all should be valued. “Age Wars” seem to be at least fueled by media… if not created by media, and it truly IS a cause for concern. Do we want rioting in the streets here in the U.S. as it is in other places? Do we want, as one MSN columnist suggested, “Death Panels” for the elderly and/or infirmed? What I’ve been asking myself a lot lately is WHY are news organizations (like Time magazine) reporting erroneous information? What purpose is to be served or agenda met? More important, what’s behind the false hype? Is it simply that there’s not enough bonafide news to report? Or is it something more?

  2. AuntLeesie says:

    (continued)
    I appreciate your insights, and especially the research you’ve done for this series, Robert. It’d be less cause for concern if more journalists were equally responsible in checking their facts… or simply acknowledging the natural progression of maturity and aging. Young adults, as they always have, bring fresh perspective to complex problems. Seniors, especially older ones, have the life experience and wisdom to know what is or is not likely to fly as solutions. The Boomers, who brought about much of the technological explosion now “normal” to our kids, have had the responsibility to instill lasting values in a changing society. Society has always changed with each subsequent generation. When we can understand each role–the importance and truth of each role–we’re more likely to find successful solutions to problems. Working together is far better than division. We’re stronger when we’re united in purpose BECAUSE of our differences. Don’t you think?

    As an aside… inquiring minds want to know… how do most young adults view those who are in their eighties and nineties? Or those of their parents generation?

  3. Aaron Bevan says:

    As a Gen-X member, I really enjoyed your paper on Millenials. First, I didn’t know they named your generation yet. You’all called Millenials. Second, the picture references ate funny and true. Last, I believe this subject is advantageous for all generations to read and retain. Thanks Robert, Ab.

  4. Daisy Duck says:

    Great reporting, Robert! Wish all journalists checked out their facts as you did. Keep up the good work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: